Was the USMNT Overrated by Bettors During the 2026 World Cup?

Michael Thompson

The party ended in Seattle. On July 6, Belgium walked into a stadium packed with 66,925 mostly American fans and beat the USMNT 4-1, closing the book on the best World Cup a U.S. men’s team has played since 2002. The tournament has moved on to a France vs Spain semifinal, but bettors are still holding the receipts, and they raise a fair question: was the USMNT overrated by bettors this summer?

Back in June we asked whether this was the best USMNT ever. This is the colder follow-up. We pulled the handle reports, the odds ladder, and the matchup prices, and the honest answer splits right down the middle: the odds stayed sane. The tickets didn’t.

Michael Thompson, betting strategy analyst at BettingSite.net
Last updated ✓ Fact-checked

The Most-Bet Team in the Tournament

Start with the part nobody disputes: no team at this World Cup moved money like the U.S. did. A home tournament, a 48-team field, and legal sportsbooks live across most of the country added up to something the industry had never seen. Caesars called the USA vs Bosnia and Herzegovina Round of 32 match the most-engaged soccer event in the company’s history: its highest soccer handle ever, the most wagers it had ever taken on a soccer match, and the most unique customers it had ever seen bet one.1

The books weren’t shy about what all that one-way traffic meant. FOX Sports reported the USA was already a substantial liability at the SuperBook before the Bosnia game even kicked off, and the SuperBook’s John Murray saw exactly what was coming next: “USA vs. Belgium is gonna be huge.” BetMGM’s trading team said flat out that it expected USA vs Belgium to be its most-bet game of the tournament and one of its biggest liabilities.

A quick translation for anyone new to the term: a liability is one-sided risk. It means so much money has landed on one outcome that the book takes a real hit if it cashes. When three different sportsbooks describe the same team that way in the same tournament, that’s not a hot take. That’s the sound of a country betting on itself.

What the Odds Ladder Actually Said

Here’s where the story gets more interesting than “America bet dumb.” Because while the tickets piled up, the outright price never once called the USMNT a contender. Caesars’ title odds on the U.S. moved like this through the tournament:

Moment in the tournamentUSMNT title odds (Caesars)Implied probability
Before the opener+5000About 2%
After the 4-1 Paraguay win (June 12)+4000About 2.4%
After the 2-0 Australia win (June 19)+3000About 3.2%
After the 3-2 loss to Türkiye (June 25)+3000About 3.2%
After the 2-0 Bosnia win (July 1)+2500About 3.8%

Run those numbers through our odds calculator and the picture is consistent: from the first kick to the last, the market gave the USMNT somewhere between a 2% and 4% chance of lifting the trophy. That’s longshot territory the entire way. The price shortened as the wins stacked up, which is what prices do, but it never came within shouting distance of France, Spain, or Argentina.

So if “overrated” means the market priced the U.S. like a title threat, the verdict is an easy acquittal. The futures board treated them as a fun sprinkle, priced them like a fun sprinkle, and buried them in the odds column where fun sprinkles live. The problem showed up somewhere else.

Was the USMNT Overrated in the Belgium Match?

The Round of 16 is where price and patriotism finally collided. In the days before the match, BetMGM had it close to a coin flip: USA +160, Belgium +160, draw +230 on the three-way moneyline, with Belgium a hair ahead in the to-advance market at -115 to the USA’s -110. Then the money did what it had done all tournament. By matchday, ESPN’s consensus had the USA at -125 to advance, DraftKings had moved the Americans from -115 all the way to -140, and the books were reporting 92% of to-advance money at BetMGM and 81% of the same handle at Caesars sitting on the USA.2

Step back and look at that price. The June FIFA rankings had Belgium 9th in the world and the USA 17th.3 Home crowd and tournament form are worth something, but the crowd’s money had turned the lower-ranked team into the favorite. That’s not analysis moving a line. That’s demand.

SnapshotUSA vs Belgium, to advanceWhat it said
July 2 (BetMGM)Belgium -115 / USA -110A coin flip, Belgium a hair ahead
Matchday consensus (ESPN)USA -125 / Belgium +105The USA now favored
Matchday (DraftKings)USA -140, up from -115The steepest USA shade on the board

And the U.S. had no excuses available. Folarin Balogun’s straight red card against Bosnia carried an automatic one-match ban that should have ruled him out, but FIFA’s disciplinary committee suspended the ban for a one-year probationary period days before kickoff, a decision that followed a reported call from President Trump to FIFA president Gianni Infantino and left Belgium’s federation fuming.4 For betting purposes the fine print didn’t matter: the USMNT took the field at full strength.

Then Belgium took the game apart. Charles De Ketelaere tapped one in inside eight minutes, Malik Tillman’s free kick briefly leveled it, and De Ketelaere answered within two minutes. The night’s defining moment came in the 57th, when U.S. keeper Matt Freese, pressured while clearing outside his box, passed the ball straight to Hans Vanaken for an empty-net goal, before Romelu Lukaku added a fourth in stoppage time. Pochettino didn’t reach for excuses afterward, admitting his team simply wasn’t good enough on the night. The underlying numbers agreed with him: by Opta’s count, Belgium won expected goals 2.15 to 0.67 and out-shot the USA 15 to 7.5

That’s the tell. A team getting even money against a stronger opponent, with the books openly announcing that all the money was on one side, is the textbook picture of a shaded line. Bettors taking USA +160 weren’t getting a sharp price on a live underdog. They were paying retail for the flag.

The Case Against Calling the USMNT Overrated

Now the other side of the ledger, because it’s real. This was, by results, a historically good U.S. World Cup. The USMNT won Group D with 6 points, the program’s best group-stage finish ever, and scored 11 goals across the tournament, another program record, even with the 3-2 stumble against Türkiye on a last-minute goal. Then came the part that mattered most: the 2-0 win over Bosnia and Herzegovina was the USMNT’s first World Cup knockout-stage victory since 2002, a 24-year itch finally scratched, and the team finished that one with ten men.6 Mauricio Pochettino now owns more World Cup wins than any USMNT manager in history.

The team that ended the run was no banana peel, either. Belgium went to the quarterfinal and pushed Spain, the No. 2 team in the world, all the way to a late Mikel Merino winner before bowing out 2-1.7 Losing a knockout match to that side isn’t a scandal. It’s roughly what’s supposed to happen to the 17th-ranked team in the world, which is the quiet truth of this whole run: strip the jersey off, and the summary reads “solid mid-tier team wins its group, wins a knockout round, loses to a top-ten side.” That’s a team performing at its ranking, maybe a touch above it.

The Verdict: Overrated Where It Counted

So split the verdict, because the data does. On the futures board, no: bettors never forced the USMNT into contender pricing, and a 2-4% title chance for a team that exited in the Round of 16 is about right. But in the flow of actual money, yes. The U.S. was the most overbet team of the tournament by every measure the books shared, and being overbet and being overrated aren’t quite the same thing. Overbet describes where the tickets pile up. Overrated describes a price sitting above a team’s true chances. The crush of patriotic money turned the first into the second exactly where casual bettors live: the match markets, where a No. 17 team closed as the favorite to advance over a No. 9 team and lost by three.

We saw the same mechanism when we broke down the most overrated NFL teams by their betting odds: markets lean toward the teams the public loves, because demand moves prices in sportsbooks the same way it does everywhere else. Soccer just gave us the cleanest possible case study, with the books narrating their own liability in real time.

And when it ended, the receipts were historic on both sides of the counter. USA vs Belgium went down as the most-bet soccer game in American sportsbook history, BetMGM took more bets on it than on any NBA Finals, Stanley Cup Final, or World Series game this year, and the books that had been hammered on every U.S. win finally collected: BetMGM called the result one of its biggest winners of the year in any sport.8 The crowd bet its heart. The house cashed it.

💡 The Liability Tell
When a sportsbook says out loud that one team is its “biggest liability,” it’s telling you where the crowd’s money went. Lines get shaded toward that demand, which means the popular side is usually a worse price than the market’s honest opinion of the game. If the popular side is your team, that’s your cue to shop the line harder, size down, or sit it out and just be a fan for the night.

None of this should sour the summer. The USMNT delivered records, a knockout win a generation of fans had never seen, and a sold-out farewell in Seattle. But the betting lesson deserves to outlive the run: the market charges a premium to bet your own team, and the hometown tax gets steepest on the biggest stages. Bet the number, not the badge. If you want to build the habits that make that instinct automatic, our betting strategy guides are the place to start.

Sources

  1. FOX Sports: 2026 World Cup Odds: USMNT Generating Record-Breaking Soccer Handle Accessed July 2026.
  2. ESPN: World Cup: USA odds shorten versus Belgium after Balogun red card reprieve Accessed July 2026.
  3. ESPN: FIFA Men’s Top 50 World Rankings: June 2026 Accessed July 2026.
  4. ESPN: USMNT’s Balogun has red card suspended; Trump asked FIFA to review Accessed July 2026.
  5. Opta Analyst: USA 1-4 Belgium Stats: De Ketelaere Leads Emphatic Win to Knock Out Co-Hosts Accessed July 2026.
  6. U.S. Soccer: USMNT vs. Belgium: Match Recap & Highlights Accessed July 2026.
  7. Yahoo Sports: Spain tops Belgium on late Mikel Merino goal, sets semifinal date with France Accessed July 2026.
  8. ESPN: U.S. World Cup loss sets betting records, big profits for house Accessed July 2026.
Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit www.ncpgambling.org
Must be 21+ to participate (18+ in DC, KY, NH, WY). Sports betting involves risk. Only wager what you can afford to lose. Sports betting availability varies by state. Check your local laws before placing any wagers.

USMNT Betting FAQ

The USMNT’s exit left a lot of bettors doing math on their own summer. Here are the questions we keep hearing now that the run is over and the tournament is rolling on without them.

Did the USMNT underperform at the 2026 World Cup?

By program history, no. The USMNT won its group with 6 points (a program best), scored a record 11 goals, and earned its first knockout-stage win since 2002 by beating Bosnia and Herzegovina before falling to Belgium. Against the market’s expectations, only slightly: by kickoff the books had made the U.S. a modest favorite to get past ninth-ranked Belgium, and the match ended 4-1 the other way.

What were the USMNT’s odds to win the 2026 World Cup?

At Caesars, the U.S. opened the tournament at +5000 and never got shorter than +2500, which works out to roughly a 2% to 4% implied chance of winning it all. The market treated them as a longshot from start to finish, even while they were setting handle records as the most-bet team in the tournament.

What does it mean when a sportsbook calls a team a liability?

It means the money is lopsided: so many bets have landed on that team that the book loses if it wins. Books manage a liability by shading the line, giving the popular side a slightly worse price. That’s why a team being every book’s stated liability is a warning sign for anyone betting that side.

What is the hometown tax in sports betting?

It’s the premium you pay when betting on the team you (and everyone around you) roots for. Heavy one-way demand pushes the price on a popular home team below fair value, so its backers get worse odds than the matchup deserves. The fix is simple: compare the price to the team’s actual strength, shop multiple books, and bet the number rather than the badge.

  • Michael Thompson

    Michael Thompson is BettingSite.net's betting strategy analyst. He covers the math behind closing-line value, line shopping, hedging and bankroll management, and shows the numbers before the conclusion. Every piece he writes is edited by Paul Wilson, BettingSite.net's editor-in-chief.

Leave a Comment

BettingSite.net Logo

BettingSite.net is your go-to source for unbiased reviews of the best online betting sites. Our mission is to provide comprehensive, reliable information to help you make informed decisions and enhance your betting experience.

Join Our Community


Gambling Help Online Logo
GambleAware Logo
The National Council on Problem Gambling Logo
21+