The two biggest sportsbooks in America both started life as fantasy sports companies. That isn’t a fun piece of trivia. It’s basically the whole story of how we got here. The relationship between fantasy sports and betting runs a lot deeper than most people realize, because fantasy built the audience, the apps, and the habits that the entire modern betting boom was stacked on top of. Here’s how fantasy fandom quietly shaped what you bet, how you bet, and where the market is heading next.
The Two Biggest Sportsbooks Were Fantasy Companies First
FanDuel launched in 2009. DraftKings followed in 2012. For most of their early lives, neither one was a sportsbook at all. They were daily fantasy sports sites, where you paid an entry fee, drafted a lineup of real players, and won cash based on how those players performed that night. Millions of people signed up, funded accounts, and got very comfortable putting money on individual athletes.
Then, in May 2018, the Supreme Court struck down the federal ban on sports betting, and the ground shifted overnight. The fantasy giants were sitting on exactly what a new sportsbook needs most: a huge base of sports-obsessed users, trusted apps, working payment systems, and marketing muscle. So they flipped. Today DraftKings and FanDuel are the two dominant sportsbooks in the country, and the market they pivoted into is enormous. Americans wagered nearly $167 billion with legal sportsbooks in 2025, and the books kept a record $16.96 billion of it.1
None of that gets built from a standing start. The fantasy years were the on-ramp. When betting went legal, the fantasy companies didn’t have to find customers. They already had them.
How Fantasy Sports and Betting Became One Audience
The overlap between the two crowds is massive, and it’s the quiet engine behind everything else. Research from the Fantasy Sports & Gaming Association counts roughly 57 million fantasy players and about 66 million sports bettors across the U.S. and Canada, and those two groups are heavily the same people.2 Fantasy isn’t a separate hobby that lives next door to betting. For a huge share of players, it’s the front door.
It makes sense when you think about what fantasy actually trains you to do. It teaches you to stop watching a game to see who wins and start watching to see whether one specific player hits a number. It gets you researching matchups, tracking usage, and staking something on the answer. That’s the exact mental muscle sports betting runs on. Fantasy just built it first, in a setting that felt like a game instead of a wager.
This isn’t just a hunch, either. A peer-reviewed study in Sport Marketing Quarterly built a model showing that specific personality traits predict which fantasy players go on to bet on sports.3 In other words, the crossover is patterned and predictable, not random. The fantasy audience is the single most reliable pool of future bettors anyone has, which is why the operators fought so hard to own it.
Fantasy Turned Player Props Into the Hottest Bet in the Book
Here’s where fantasy stopped just feeding betting and started reshaping it. If you play fantasy, you don’t sit down on Sunday asking “who’s going to win.” You ask “does my running back clear 80 yards.” That question is a player prop. An entire generation showed up to betting already fluent in it.
Sportsbooks noticed, and they built for it. Player props and same-game parlays went from a niche afterthought to the fastest-growing corner of the menu. A same-game parlay is really just a fantasy card you can bet: stack a quarterback’s passing yards with his receiver’s catches and the team total, all on one game. The bet-builder tools that let you assemble those are a direct descendant of the fantasy lineup, and we break down how they work in our guide to bet builders.
This is the clearest fingerprint fantasy left on betting trends. The products that grew the fastest are the ones that feel the most like fantasy. That’s not an accident. It’s the market giving a fantasy-trained audience exactly what it already wanted to bet on.
The Pick’em Games That Blurred the Line Into Betting
At some point fantasy didn’t just influence betting. It started turning into it. Apps like PrizePicks and Underdog built a product called pick’em, where you choose whether a handful of players will go over or under a projected stat line and combine those picks for a bigger payout. Read that back slowly. That’s a player-prop parlay wearing a fantasy name tag.
Regulators reached the same conclusion. In July 2025, California’s attorney general issued a formal opinion that daily fantasy sports, including both draft-style contests and pick’em, count as illegal sports betting under state law and should be treated the same as any other wager.4 States including Arizona, Virginia, Wyoming, Florida, and New York landed in similar territory on pick’em, with Arizona flatly calling it proposition betting. It’s a state-by-state patchwork of opinions and enforcement rather than one national rule, but the direction is unmistakable.
The fallout tells you how thin the line got. PrizePicks and Underdog rebuilt their games into peer-to-peer formats, where you compete against other users instead of the house, to keep operating in wary states. PrizePicks also paid about $15 million to settle claims that it had run unlicensed contests in New York. When the law can’t cleanly tell your fantasy contest apart from a sportsbook, the two worlds have basically merged.
Prediction Markets Are the Newest Blurred Line
The latest twist comes from a different direction entirely, but it rhymes with the fantasy playbook. Prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket let you trade “event contracts” on how a game will turn out. Legally they’re regulated as commodities by a federal agency, not as sportsbooks. Functionally, buying a contract on your team is placing a bet, just dressed up in the language of a trading exchange.
And it’s exploding. By one industry estimate, during this summer’s World Cup prediction markets handled volume equal to about 27% of all legal U.S. sports betting, up from roughly 9% at the start of the year, with even FanDuel and DraftKings feeling the pressure.5 It’s the same move fantasy pulled a decade ago: take something that walks and talks like betting, frame it as skill or as a market, and watch a sports-obsessed audience pour in. We dug into how that fight plays out in our look at whether AI agents can beat humans at prediction markets.
What the Fantasy Sports and Betting Boom Means for Your Bets
If you came up through fantasy, you’re starting with a real advantage. You already know rosters, matchups, roles, and usage, and that knowledge translates cleanly to player props and game-script bets. The instincts you built drafting lineups are genuinely useful at the sportsbook. That part is a gift.
The trap is what fantasy quietly left out: the house’s cut. A fantasy pick’em or a friendly league hides how the price is built, but a real sportsbook bakes in the vig on every line, and the props and parlays that feel most like fantasy tend to carry the fattest margins. So use the fantasy brain. Just respect that betting adds a tax fantasy trained you to ignore. If you want to sharpen the habits that actually survive that tax, our betting strategy guides are the place to start.
Sources
- American Gaming Association: Commercial Gaming Revenue Hits $78.7 Billion in 2025 Published February 2026.
- Fantasy Sports & Gaming Association: FSGA Industry Research (fantasy and sports betting participation)
- Sport Marketing Quarterly: Which Fantasy Sports Players Will Bet on Sports? A Trait-Based Predictive Model Published 2023.
- iGaming Business: California AG rules daily fantasy sports is betting Published July 2025.
- Fortune: Prediction markets swell to 27% of sports bets during World Cup Published July 2026.
Must be 21+ to participate (18+ in DC, KY, NH, WY). Sports betting involves risk. Only wager what you can afford to lose. Sports betting availability varies by state. Check your local laws before placing any wagers.
Fantasy Sports and Betting FAQ
The questions we hear most about how fantasy fandom and real-money betting ended up so tangled together.
Did FanDuel and DraftKings really start as fantasy sports companies?
Yes. FanDuel launched in 2009 and DraftKings in 2012, both as daily fantasy sports sites where users paid entry fees to draft lineups for cash prizes. After the Supreme Court struck down the federal sports betting ban in 2018, both pivoted to sportsbooks and are now the two largest in the United States. Their fantasy user bases gave them a massive head start.
Are daily fantasy pick’em games the same as sports betting?
Regulators increasingly say yes. Pick’em products let you choose whether players go over or under a stat line and combine those picks, which functions like a player-prop parlay. In July 2025 California’s attorney general ruled daily fantasy, including pick’em, is illegal sports betting, and several other states reached similar conclusions, pushing operators like PrizePicks and Underdog toward peer-to-peer formats.
Why did player props and same-game parlays get so popular?
Fantasy trained millions of fans to focus on individual player performance rather than just which team wins, and a player prop is exactly that bet. Same-game parlays let you stack several player outcomes on one game, essentially betting a fantasy card. They also carry higher margins for sportsbooks, so operators heavily promote them.
What are prediction markets like Kalshi?
Prediction markets such as Kalshi and Polymarket let you trade contracts on real-world outcomes, including sports results, and are regulated federally as commodities rather than as sportsbooks. By one industry estimate, during this summer’s World Cup they handled volume equal to roughly 27% of all legal U.S. sports betting, up from about 9% at the start of the year. Legally they are distinct from betting, but functionally they behave much like it.




