Sports betting is supposed to be about edges, value, and disciplined bankroll management. And then someone turns 85 cents into a $147,000 parlay ticket and you start questioning everything you thought you knew.
The truth is, some of the greatest wins in betting history came from bets that looked absolutely ridiculous when they were placed. We’re talking 5,000-to-1 odds, grocery baggers winning Super Bowls, and college kids beating the Soviet Union. These are the longshot stories that make you laugh, shake your head, and maybe — just maybe — throw a few bucks on something stupid this weekend.
Here are 10 of the dumbest bets that actually won, ranked from wild to completely unhinged.
The Dumbest Bets That Actually Won
| Rank | Bet | Odds | Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | Mine That Bird wins Kentucky Derby | 50-1 | 2009 |
| 9 | Appalachian State beats #5 Michigan | +3300 | 2007 |
| 8 | $5 first-basket parlay pays $113,500 | 22,700-1 | 2024 |
| 7 | Buster Douglas KOs Mike Tyson | 42-1 | 1990 |
| 6 | St. Louis Rams win the Super Bowl | 300-1 | 1999 |
| 5 | $2.47 college football parlay pays $279K | 11.6M-1 | 2024 |
| 4 | Rulon Gardner wins Olympic Gold | 2,000-1 | 2000 |
| 3 | St. Louis Cardinals win World Series | 999-1 | 2011 |
| 2 | 85-cent parlay hits 13 of 14 legs | 17.3M-1 | 2024 |
| 1 | Leicester City wins the Premier League | 5,000-1 | 2016 |
10. Mine That Bird Wins the Kentucky Derby (50-1)
Mine That Bird had everything working against him: a terrible name, no testicles (he was a gelding), and the fact that he was purchased for just $9,500. The horse was 50-1 on the morning line at the 2009 Kentucky Derby, and most handicappers didn’t even bother mentioning him in their previews.
Then he ran dead last for the first half of the race, swung to the outside, and blew past the entire field to win by nearly seven lengths. The race caller literally didn’t know who was winning. Mine That Bird went on to earn over $2.2 million in his career, which is a pretty solid return on a $9,500 investment.
9. Appalachian State Beats #5 Michigan (+3300)
In Week 1 of the 2007 college football season, Appalachian State — a Division 1-AA team — walked into the Big House as 33-point underdogs against the fifth-ranked Michigan Wolverines. No 1-AA team had ever beaten a ranked 1-A opponent. The line was so absurd that most sportsbooks didn’t even offer it.
App State won 34-32, blocking a last-second Michigan field goal to seal the upset. Michigan spiraled into one of the worst seasons in program history, eventually hiring Jim Harbaugh — the coach behind another entry on this list (Stanford’s 41-point upset of USC later that same season) — to rebuild the program. The Circle of Life, college football edition.
8. The $5 First-Basket Parlay That Paid $113,500 (22,700-1)
On a random November Saturday in 2024, a bettor looked at a four-game NBA slate with zero marquee matchups and decided to get creative. They placed a $5 two-leg parlay on FanDuel: Walker Kessler of the Utah Jazz and Dorian Finney-Smith of the Brooklyn Nets to each score the first basket of their respective games — and how they’d score them.
Kessler opened the scoring with a 3-foot jump hook. Finney-Smith hit a floater from just outside the paint. Both legs cashed. The odds: 22,700-to-1. The payout: $113,500 from a $5 bet. The bettor, according to ESPN’s year-in-review report, could not be reached for comment. Probably too busy celebrating.
7. Buster Douglas KOs Mike Tyson (42-1)
By the numbers alone, Buster Douglas at 42-1 doesn’t crack the top five on this list. But context matters. Mike Tyson wasn’t just undefeated at 37-0 with 33 knockouts — he was the most terrifying human being on the planet. Opponents were visibly scared of him before the opening bell. Douglas was a journeyman with four losses and zero signature wins.
In Tokyo on February 11, 1990, Douglas got knocked down in the eighth round and everyone assumed it was over. Instead, he got up, rallied, and knocked Tyson out cold in the tenth. It was the end of an era. Tyson was never the same fighter. Douglas lost his next fight to Evander Holyfield and was never relevant again. But for one night in Tokyo, the dumbest bet on the board was the smartest bet in the building.
6. Kurt Warner’s Grocery Store to Super Bowl Run (300-1)
The 1999 St. Louis Rams were terrible. They’d been terrible for years. Their big offseason move was signing quarterback Trent Green, who promptly tore his ACL before the season started. The backup? A guy named Kurt Warner who had been stocking shelves at a grocery store a few years earlier and playing in the Arena Football League.
Warner took over, threw 41 touchdowns, won the MVP, and led the “Greatest Show on Turf” to a Super Bowl victory over the Tennessee Titans. The Rams opened the season at 300-1 to win it all. Anyone who bet them preseason — and there weren’t many — cashed one of the greatest futures tickets in NFL history. Warner went on to a Hall of Fame career. The grocery store presumably found a new stock boy.
5. The $2.47 College Football Parlay That Almost Paid $500K
In 2024, an ESPN BET customer in New York placed a $2.47 bet on a 19-leg college football parlay at +11,635,957 odds. That’s 11.6 million-to-one. The kind of odds where the sportsbook’s algorithm probably laughed while generating the ticket.
Eighteen of the 19 legs hit. The final leg — BYU -12 against Houston — came down to a 2-point conversion. BYU won 30-18 but failed the conversion, causing the spread to push instead of cover. Instead of $500,000+, the bettor settled for $279,262.97. We’d feel bad for them, but turning $2.47 into $279K is still one of the most absurd wins in betting history. The lesson? Even when you lose, you can still win — if your bet is dumb enough.
4. Rulon Gardner Beats the Unbeatable (2,000-1)
Quick: name a Greco-Roman wrestler. You can’t, unless you remember Rulon Gardner — and the only reason you remember him is because of what he did at the 2000 Sydney Olympics.
Gardner went up against Alexander Karelin, a Russian legend who hadn’t lost a match in 13 years. Karelin was so dominant that he’d gone six straight years without giving up a single point. Gardner had never finished better than fifth in international competition. The odds were 2,000-to-1.
Gardner won 1-0 in overtime, and the sports world collectively lost its mind. It remains one of the greatest upsets in Olympic history. Gardner later tried MMA, retired after one fight, and nearly died in a snowmobile accident. Karelin went into Russian politics. As you do.
3. The Cardinals’ Impossible World Series Run (999-1)
With 15 games left in the 2011 MLB season, the St. Louis Cardinals were 4.5 games behind the Atlanta Braves for the National League wild card spot. Sportsbooks had them at 999-1 to win the World Series. The math said they were done. The Braves just needed to not completely collapse.
The Braves completely collapsed. Atlanta went 9-18 down the stretch while the Cardinals ripped off an 11-4 run to steal the wild card on the final day of the season. Then they beat the Rangers in one of the most dramatic World Series ever played, including a Game 6 where they were one strike away from elimination — twice — before David Freese hit a walk-off home run in the 11th inning.
If you had a 999-1 ticket on the Cardinals, that Game 6 probably took years off your life. Worth it.
2. The 85-Cent Parlay Heard Around the World (17.3 Million-to-1)
On the morning after the 2024 Super Bowl, a 26-year-old construction worker in Baltimore had exactly 85 cents left in his FanDuel account. Most people would’ve withdrawn the dust and moved on. This guy went all-in on a 14-leg, multisport parlay at +17,353,716 odds.
The ticket included the NBA All-Star Game over, seven division winners across the NBA and NHL, four boxing matches, UConn winning the NCAA basketball title, and Ohio State winning the College Football Playoff. If everything hit, the payout was $147,507.44.
Thirteen of the 14 legs cashed. The only remaining leg was Ohio State winning the CFP. FanDuel offered $7,000 to cash out before the Buckeyes’ playoff run. The bettor held. After Ohio State lost to Michigan in the regular season, he sold the ticket on WagerWire — a secondary market for pending bets — for $16,750. That’s a 1,970,488% return on investment from 85 cents. If you’re building a bankroll, this is technically one way to do it. We don’t recommend it.
1. Leicester City Wins the Premier League (5,000-1)
This is the one. The greatest longshot in the history of organized sports betting. Leicester City — a club that had been fighting relegation the previous season — opened the 2015-16 Premier League campaign at 5,000-to-1 to win the title. For context, those were the same odds as finding the Loch Ness Monster or Elvis being confirmed alive.
Leicester didn’t just win. They dominated. While traditional powerhouses Manchester United, Liverpool, and Chelsea finished 5th, 8th, and 10th respectively, the Foxes ran away with the title behind Jamie Vardy’s goals and N’Golo Kante’s midfield dominance. It was the kind of season that doesn’t happen in modern football. The money, the resources, the talent gap — everything said it was impossible.
British bookmakers paid out an estimated £25 million to punters who backed Leicester at various long odds throughout the season. One bettor reportedly turned a £50 bet into £200,000. Another cashed out early for £72,000 on a £5 bet. It was the single most expensive result in UK bookmaking history, and it’ll probably never happen again. But that’s what they said before it happened the first time.
What These Longshots Have in Common

Every story on this list shares one thing: the market said it was basically impossible, and it happened anyway. That’s the beauty — and the danger — of sports betting. The odds exist for a reason, and 99.9% of the time, the 5,000-1 shot loses. But that 0.1% is what keeps people coming back.
The smart takeaway isn’t to start firing longshot parlays every weekend. It’s to understand that betting odds reflect probability, not certainty. The sportsbook’s edge comes from being right most of the time, not all of the time. And occasionally, the universe decides to remind everyone that anything can happen.
If you do want to take a shot on a longshot, keep it small. The 85-cent parlay guy didn’t risk his rent money. The Leicester City bettors threw £5 or £50 on a dream. That’s the right approach — treat longshots as entertainment, not strategy. If you want actual strategy, check out how sharp bettors separate themselves from the squares.
And if you’re worried about getting carried away chasing the next impossible win, we wrote a whole piece on why FOMO betting destroys your bankroll. Read it before you put $5 on a 22,700-to-1 first-basket parlay. Or don’t. We’re not your parents.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are the most common questions bettors ask about longshot bets and improbable wins.
What is the biggest longshot bet that ever won?
Leicester City winning the 2015-16 Premier League at 5,000-to-1 odds is widely considered the greatest longshot in sports betting history. British bookmakers paid out an estimated £25 million to bettors who backed the Foxes.
What are the odds of winning a longshot parlay?
Longshot parlays with odds of 10,000-to-1 or higher have roughly a 0.01% chance of hitting. The more legs you add, the lower the probability — but the higher the potential payout. Most sharp bettors avoid parlays with more than 3-4 legs.
Has anyone ever turned a small bet into a huge payout?
Yes. In 2024, a bettor turned 85 cents into a 14-leg parlay at +17,353,716 odds. Thirteen of 14 legs hit, and the ticket was sold for $16,750 on a secondary market. Another bettor turned $5 into $113,500 on a two-leg first-basket parlay.
Should I bet on longshots?
Longshot bets should be treated as entertainment, not strategy. Keep the stakes small — a few dollars at most — and never chase longshots with money you can’t afford to lose. The vast majority of longshot bets lose, which is why the payouts are so large when they hit.
What was the biggest upset in sports history?
The 1980 US Olympic hockey team beating the Soviet Union at 1,000-to-1 odds is often cited as the greatest upset in sports history. In terms of point spread, Appalachian State beating #5 Michigan as a 33-point underdog in 2007 is one of the largest college football upsets ever.
Gambling Problem? Call or text 1-800-GAMBLER. Must be 21+ to wager. Please gamble responsibly. Sports betting involves risk — never bet more than you can afford to lose. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, visit ncpgambling.org or call 1-800-GAMBLER. Self-exclusion programs are available in most legal betting states.



